When I was a kid, I used to ask my parents for book recommendations. My (unreliable) memories suggest that most of the time, it was a miss (as in, I ended up not liking whatever they recommended). In reality, it was probably more like 50/50.
I remember my dad telling me that he loved Fenimore Cooper and Walter Scott. I tried reading both – and hated it. Couldn’t get through Ivanhoe. I did make my way through “The Pathfinder” and “The Last of the Mohicans”, but really did not like either one. (Believe it or not, back in the USSR, we owned a big collection of works by Fenimore Cooper, in 6 big fat volumes).
My mom told me she LOVED Oliver Twist and got me the book from the library. I hated it. In fact, I seem to have developed a powerful dislike for anything by Dickens. Another book she loved – Serezha by Vera Panova – even as a kid I realized that the writing was beautiful, but it was so, so heartbreakingly emotional and sad that I couldn’t deal with it.
I conveniently don’t remember any books that my parents recommended and I loved. It must have happened – we had a ton of books at home, and many books I read and re-read multiple times. Sherlock Holmes – I loved those stories. Yet, I remember sneakily reading it when my parents weren’t home (not sure why I felt I had to hide it). I think my mom may have talked about Fahrenheit 451 (my grandparents had a copy) – I liked it a lot. I learned recently that she loved Jane Eyre – I also liked it when I read it as a teen but I can’t remember ever discussing it with her.
Reading is a solitary kind of thing. It’s just you and the book, but you get to bring all your baggage, experiences, anxieties, and fears and all that affects how you experience that specific book. Liking a book can depend on so many things, but timing seems to be super important. When you get to read the right book at the right time, it feels like the author is taking to you, like they know you, like you are soulmates. Reading the book at the wrong time – best case scenario, you feel like you don’t get it. Or (worse) you develop a near-allergic reaction to the author (ahem, Dickens).